Why The United States Real Estate Downturn Will Be Much Different Than Japan’s

AlpineThere is a great deal of discussion going on in the real estate world that the real estate downturn in the United States is going to mimic the 10 year downturn that Japan went through in the 1990’s. The fear of rampant deflation or at best stagflation is often the fear raised by those who profess doom. Chicken Little works well with these folks.

However, after reading a speech by Edward Lincoln, director of the Center for Japan-US Business and Economic Studies and Professor of Economics at New York University Stern School of Business, most of the fears that cross my mind at 4 am in the morning have been put to rest.

Japan-houseHis general thesis is that the flexibility of the United States economy is designed to weather financial storms much easier than the central command economy of Japan. Add to that much stricter and tighter financial controls, problems that linger in Japan get recognized and fixed much quicker in the United States.

This is an enlightening speech and I do hope you have time to read it. Lincoln does not sugar coat our problems, he points out some very glaring ones. But overall he shows how the US economy is resilient and can avoid severe downturns like many are projecting.

On the real estate side, part of the difference may be simply in both economic growth and in population growth. In terms of economic growth, we’re growing at 3.0-3.5% a year, on average, over long periods of time. Japan is now down to probably 1.0-2.0% a year. As you grow, you have more demand for office buildings and things like that. That demand growth is stronger in the United States, and should be stronger over the next decade in the United States, than in Japan.

And similarly with population. We still have a growing population. Japan does not. Japan now has a shrinking population. It is shrinking particularly rapidly at the younger end of the demographic chain, and that means that we are going to see fewer and fewer and fewer new households looking for a place to live. So the longer-term prospects are, I think, for a fairly quick recovery in real estate prices – or at least a turn back up, if not a total recovery – in the United States.  via Asia Times Online

Related posts:
  1. Top 10 Fastest Growing States in the United States 2007-2008
  2. Top 10 Cities For Relocations in the United States
  3. International Buyers Pass on Buying United States Real Estate
  4. Saudi Fund Investing 1.1 Billion in United States and United Kingdom
  5. Japan Ditching Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Model

There Are 3 Responses So Far. »

  1. [...] on saving money and cutting corners ran amuck.  I distinctly remember reading an article  in the early ’90s suggesting that one way to save a buck was to squish all your soap remnants into a ball to make a [...]

  2. I don’t think that the U.S. is like Japan. Nonetheless, this article is –in my opinion -naive and hopeful, rather than reality based.

    Two points:

    >Most economists will be very surprised if the US economu grows 3% in either of the next two years.

    > The own to rent rations are –too high. See this post by Paul Krugman, and the associated graph:

    http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/04/08/permanently-high-home-prices/

    The other item to look at is the Index of Consumer Sentiment from the University of Michigan. The last time it was lower than this was before Ronald Reagan took office.

    http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/04/11/depressed-consumers/

  3. [...] que certains blogueurs se demandent assez anxieusement si les États-Unis vont mettre autant de temps à se remettre de la crise [...]

Post a Response

« Back to text comment
  • Popular

    Most Comments

    Search

    Tags

    Archives

  • Recent Comments

    • The question is when are they going to release them on the market. Las Vegas leads the nation in ...
      Tony Sena | 19Nov09 | More
    • I keep seeing mentions of Florida's market getting better in multiple blogs. I'm increasingly under the assumption that at least ...
      Cary NC Homes for Sale | 19Nov09 | More
    • I would like to know more about it. I need to know how you file for it. Please let me ...
      Kala | 19Nov09 | More
    • Great blog, keep the great content coming!
      NickWaltersRE | 19Nov09 | More
    • If you want to succeed, do not say "we can prevent this in the future." Live in reality. ...
      Stephen Davis | 19Nov09 | More
    • Don't worry. Bail out number 2 on the way!
      Stephen Davis | 19Nov09 | More
    • The price of the property depends on its quality and the deal between the management. Good and wise choices are ...
      beaumont houses for sale | 19Nov09 | More
    • This is a sign that the real state industry is about to rise again maybe not on its peak but ...
      houses in beaumont | 19Nov09 | More
    • I don't have experience at actualy working in tha automotive bussinnes, but have experience working in a warehouse invironment. ...
      paula schmidt | 19Nov09 | More
    • We are seeing a strong sellers market in those areas that were hardest hit with the downturn. One nearby city ...
      Bob | 18Nov09 | More
  • Statistics

  • Friends

  • Recent Friends Visiting

  • Subscribe





    Get Updates Delivered Daily By E-Mail:

    Delivered by FeedBurner